[continued from below]
If I were really in love, my soul would be humming with romantic music. I would be reciting Shakespearean sonnets, imagining the design of the Grecian urn. Comparing myself to Prince Myshkin, Romeo, Richard Burton. Grand passion? No. Instead, a sinking, hopeless feeling - a dumb, unstoppable empathy - wobbly knees, a gnawing in my stomach, a sense of falling apart.
And Rachel’s emotions? She sat down again, in the middle of the sofa, the exact point she’d been sitting before going to the lavatory. She nursed the undrunk whisky in her lap, just as she had a few moments earlier. Couldn’t she do something different, something unpredictable, something which subverted my father’s image of her vulgar dullness? Frustratingly not. In her terror, all Rachel could do was conform to his expectations.
“Mr Perfect, I know I shouldn’t have done it.” She frowned at her tears. “My dad’s really angry.”
“And he” I added, “he thinks it’s best too, if Rachel has an abortion.” Or so she’d told me, on the train.
“‘They were all honourable men.’”
“My dad’s a builder.”
“It’s a quotation from Shakespeare” I explained.
But literature was not the subject of today’s tutorial. My father opened Kant's A Critique of Pure Reason at a passage he had already marked, apparently for an occasion like this. With a slight shake of the head, he raised himself up to his full height. “‘Act as if the maxim of thy action were to become by thy will a universal law of nature.’”
“Is it that Shakespeare again?”
“Not exactly.”
“You see, Rachel, Kant is trying to explain the rational basis of morality. Even if God did not exist...” My father was preparing for a long exposition.
“My mum says if there is a God, He wouldn’t have let granny live so long.”
“But Kant would say that is not, in itself, a justification of euthanasia. This imperative isn’t conditional, it’s categ...”
“Ethu - what?”
“This is ridiculous, dad. Rachel and I didn’t come here for a philosophy lesson. We need your help. There is… we have - that is Rachel has - a very specific problem. Abstract reasoning won’t help.”
“Simon has never been very good at applying principles to every day situations.”
What? To my face, he had only ever criticised my spelling. “It’s quite simple, really. The Categorical Imperative means that if you do something, you must be prepared for everyone else to do it. So, logically, if you have your child killed before it’s born, you must approve of every child being killed…”
“Mum says…”
“Including yourself, Rachel. What right have you to exist, if you deny that right to your son?”
“Dad, it could be a daughter.”
“Son implies daughter, as you well know. So you see my dear, any action entails a belief, which entails another belief. And as that would mean the end of the human race...”
“Not everybody who gets pregnant wants an abortion.”
“Probably more women do than you realise, Simon.” He looked me straight in the eyes, as if the remark had personal significance.
“Dad, this is a very specific situation...”
“So you keep telling me.”
“... Rachel is only seventeen. Her boy friend doesn’t want to know. It was all a mistake. She lives in a small village, where people gossip...”. Excuses, special pleading. Like inventing reasons why I should be allowed to stay up late. Surely, there were principles on my side, too? Rachel’s side.
“Gossip should not be the basis of anyone’s morality.”
Yes, but… And so on. I had never dared disagree with my father’s philosophical meanderings before. No point. Hot air. No relevance. And now I could see it was a smokescreen. Underneath his sophisticated liberalism, there lurked a strict dad, like everyone else’s. I felt furious with myself for never seeing it before.